Tue, Feb 21, 2017 | updated 10:45 AM IST

Our predictions about others' pain, pleasure are less accurate: Study

Updated: Sep 13, 2016 07:45 IST

Washington D.C. [USA], Sept. 13 (ANI): A new study says that the predictions we make about others are less accurate when we have information about the groups they belong to, such as which political party or sports team they are rooting for.

On the same note, every day, millions of people, including senators, doctors, and teachers make consequential decisions that depend on predicting how other people will feel when they experience gains or setbacks.

This research suggests that our reliance on stereotypes about social groups interferes with accurately predicting how others will feel.

Most of the decisions that we make in our daily lives, whether choosing sandwiches, vacations, or medical procedures, involve predictions about how much pleasure or pain we'll experience given various possible outcomes.

This kind of prediction, what researchers call an "affective forecast," also plays a critical role in the decisions we make for others.

"Doctors might try to gauge the amount of pain people are in when deciding the kinds of drugs to prescribe them, employers might consider how happy their employees would be made by a smaller or larger holiday bonus, and politicians may consider the pain and distress that people are experiencing when deciding whether to intervene in a humanitarian crisis," noted study author Mina Cikara of Harvard University.

Considerable research has explored how people make these kinds of affective forecasts for themselves, but Cikara and collaborators Tatiana Lau (Harvard University) and Carey Morewedge (Boston University) wanted to know whether we make affective forecasts differently for other people.

"We might expect that knowing more about a person would allow us to make better predictions of how they would react to events like their team winning a game or their political party winning or losing an election, but we found the opposite," said Cikara.

In one online study, the researchers took advantage of the 2014 US Senate midterm elections to investigate.

They asked 859 participants living in the US to report their political affiliation and to rate the extent to which they identified with both the Democratic and Republican parties. Some of the participants were then asked to predict how an individual (either a "person," a "Democrat," or a "Republican") would feel the day after their party either won or lost the majority in the Senate. Other participants - so-called "experiencers" - were asked right after the midterm election how they felt about the outcome. The researchers then compared the participants' predictions with the experiencers' self-reports.

The data showed that when people made predictions for a "Republican" or a "Democrat," they tended to overestimate how happy Republicans ultimately felt about winning a majority and how sad Democrats ultimately felt about losing the majority, regardless of their own party affiliation.

When participants instead made predictions about how an unidentified "person" would feel about his or her party winning or losing the same midterm elections, their predictions were pretty similar to experiencers' reports of their feelings. Thus, people made predictions that were more extreme and less accurate when they knew the political affiliation of the person they were making predictions for.

The researchers observed similar results in the context of a college football game: the annual game between Harvard and Yale. Students tailgating before the game overestimated how unhappy Yale fans would feel when their team lost, but only when forecasting for a "Yale" fan. They were again more accurate when the school the experiencers belonged to was unspecified.

According to Cikara and her collaborators, the fact that participants made less extreme affective forecasts when they were under time pressure suggests that people probably first think about how anyone would react in the same situation and then proceed to "correct" their prediction, accounting for stereotypes about the group to which the person belongs.

The researchers hypothesize that this bias in affective forecasting may shed light on increasing political and economic polarization:

"While we haven't explicitly shown a connection between polarization and our effect, it is possible that our observed effect here has a hand in increasing the divide between two groups," said researcher Lau, adding, "When we overestimate how other members of our own group and the other group feel, and out-group members do likewise, we are building a vicious cycle of expectancy violations that can escalate conflict and other partisan divides, whether at the voting booth, at the negotiation table, or at the trade policy summit."

The study has been published in Psychological Science. (ANI)

London [UK], Feb. 21 (ANI): Looks like Yo-Yo diet is not that bad!

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): As exams are just around the corner, many students would need to declutter their rooms and organise them in a better way so that they can focus only on their studies without getting distracted due to unmanaged stuff surrounding them.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 20 (ANI): After successful openings at their existing restaurants in Saket, Pacific Mall and Mall of India (Noida), Carl's Jr.®, the iconic American burger chain is now bringing its bigger and better California-style burgers to a prime location on the Gold Course Road, OHC (One Horizon Centre), Gurugram.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 20 (ANI): When every issue these days can be resolved with the help of your mobile phone, why can't parenting be too?

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 19 (ANI): In first of its kind, Broadcast Wearables has come up with a smart fitness t-shirt that can be used for navigation and keep an account of the steps you take, calories burnt and floors climbed.

Full Story >>

New Delhi (India), Feb. 19 (ANI): Referred as India's first original independent music startup, 'Friday Night Originals' has started with a vision to make original and independent music accessible to everyone.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb.19 (ANI): The Embassy of Germany, the German School and the Indo-German Chamber of Commerce (IGCC) will jointly host a two-day German Springfest at the German House here on February 25 and 26 this year.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 19 (ANI): Red Mango is launching a new dimension to healthy eating by introducing its new line of food called "ACTIVE FOOD" with an entire variety of value meals packed with natural ingredients made fresh at the cafes.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 19 (ANI): A team of US researchers finds that youth involved in drug dealing, alcohol use disorder and gang membership have higher mortality rates, especially from homicide by firearm.

Full Story >>

Women Safety Week - Men take a Stand

Updated: Feb 18, 2017 14:06 IST

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Prior to International Women's Day on March 8, a 'Women Safety Week', from February 19-24, is being organized by NGO SLAP (Street Level Awareness Program) and Priceless Possessions in Delhi and Agra, where men are taking a lead to raise a voice for gender equality & women safety.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Keeping the nerve of the city in mind- mixture of whole India- now get one stop store in the national capital, to cater to all your needs of fashion and design.

Full Story >>

By Somdatta Saha

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 18 (ANI): A team on Briton researchers has found that while treating schizophrenia patients, add-on treatments with high-dose B-vitamins, including B6, B8 and B12, can considerably reduce symptoms of mental disorder.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 18 (ANI): Clean drinking water for everyone is one major health goal for decades, in one a shocking revelation, a study warns that while it reduces chances of catching many deadly diseases, but it can increase the risk of childhood asthma.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 18 (ANI): A steady consumption of vegetables, olive oil and moderate amounts of protein will keep you healthy! As consuming animal products and animal meat may double their chance of developing Type-2 diabetes, warns a study.

Full Story >>

New York [USA], Feb. 18 (ANI): After being pictured sitting next to empty seats at the Phillipp Plein show, American actress and comedian Whoopi Goldberg offered to sit next to U.S. President Donald Trump's daughter at the upcoming New York Fashion Week.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 18 (ANI): Think wisely before you eat those unhealthy and fattening pizzas and burgers, as a study warns that even a single dose of high fat meal can increase your chances of diabetes and fatty liver disease.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI): As the exam season approaches, one tends to hear numerous stories of examination stress among teenagers which often leads to depression and suicidal tendencies.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI): In a survey conducted by Talentedge, India's leading Ed-Tech firm, of over 1000 young professionals across eight metros, the findings revealed an interesting perspective of India's young working professionals.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI): "MOONLIIT Fest 2017", a music, food and fashion melange was a roaring success and the city dwellers loved its offerings from all across the town.

Full Story >>