Fri, Mar 24, 2017 | updated 05:39 PM IST

Moderately precise bids are persuasive: Research

Updated: Nov 11, 2016 15:12 IST

Washington D.C. (USA), Nov. 11 (ANI): Your attempt to make a precise offer for a car or a house will go in vain, if you are negotiating with some expertise in that area, according to research.

Results from a series of studies show that precise bids - for example, 9,572.36 dollars or 384,961.42 dollars - are more effective with novice negotiators, who tend to interpret higher precision as a sign of competence. Experts, on the other hand, found moderately precise bids to be most persuasive.

"Our research shows that more precise opening prices can yield you a significant negotiation advantage, but you have to know whom you're negotiating with," said researcher David D. Loschelder. "With amateurs, this number should be very precise; with experts, however, negotiators should either choose a moderate level of precision or back up their highly precise number with a compelling reason."

Loschelder became interested in the effects of precise numbers when he had to negotiate the price of a rental bicycle as a graduate student.

"The student who rented the bicycle to me asked for 34.50 euros for a period of four weeks. Not 30 euros, not 35 euros, not even 32 euros, but exactly 34.50 euros--a precise number that can't really be divided by four weeks," he explained. "As a consequence of this precision, I felt my counterpart was overly competent and I didn't even negotiate for a single cent."

Loschelder and colleagues speculated that there must be a limit to the effectiveness of precision, but their initial studies with amateur negotiators showed that very precise opening bids created surprisingly strong anchor points that shaped subsequent counteroffers and final deal terms. The researchers decided to examine the effects that such precision has in the context of real-world expertise.

In one experiment, 230 novice negotiators and 223 real-estate agents examined and evaluated a real-estate listing. Participants received the same pictures, floor plans, and other information, but the list prices they saw ranged from only two precise digits to eight precise digits. They were instructed to make a counteroffer in response to the list price and to state the highest price they would be willing to pay for the house.

The results showed that participants responded to precision differently depending on their expertise. Amateurs' counteroffers and maximum prices increased as the precision of the initial bid increased. The same was true for experts, but only up to around 5 precise digits; after this point, experts' counteroffers actually decreased as the list price became more precise.

Loschelder and colleagues found the same pattern of results when they asked novices and expert jewelers to evaluate a diamond necklace.

The researchers hypothesized that both amateurs and experts find highly precise bids to be unusual but they come to different conclusions as to why the seller made that particular bid.

"Interestingly, amateurs seem to think: 'Oh, this number is so precise, my opponent must have thought quite a bit about a fair price. He or she must be really competent,'" Loschelder explained. "In contrast, experts perceive this as too-precise a price and denigrate their opponent's competence."

Indeed, additional data indicated that perceived competence explained the responses of both amateur and expert participants. While amateurs saw more precise offers as a sign of a competent bidder, experts considered very precise bidders to be less competent than those who made moderately precise bids.

Interestingly, providing experts with a rationale for the bid seems to counteract the negative effect of precision. When car salespeople evaluated a very precise bid for a car that took various conditions - such as recent inspections, a small scratch, and long-distance usage - into account, they were willing to pay just as much as they would in response to a moderately precise bid. The results showed that including an explanation for a very precise bid made the seller appear more competent to the car experts.

Given that negotiations over things like a starting salary or the price of a house are an important part of everyday life, the findings have broad relevance:

"Whenever something is listed at a price, whenever someone opens a negotiation, price precision can come into play and you should pay close attention to your opponent's negotiation expertise," Loschelder concluded.

The study was published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. (ANI)

New Delhi [India], Mar. 24 (ANI): Various mobile applications are permitting us to track our sleeping patterns, food intake and exercise or workout patterns.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar 24 (ANI): Supporting the core theme of the annual 'Earth Hour Day', Radisson Blu Paschim Vihar is all set to ring in the day by participating and turning off the lights for an hour to save energy between 8:30 and 9:30pm.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 23 (ANI): In a successful FB Live discussion yesterday, author Amish Tripathi and Cabinet Minister of Textiles Smriti Irani discussed how today's women are warriors, fighting many emotional and intellectual battles to create their mark in every field and every sector, around the world.

Full Story >>

Rishikesh [India], March 24 (ANI): Jumpin Heights, India's Extreme Adventure Zone and India's Highest Bungy Jumping Platform successfully completed 50, 000 Bungy Jumps. To mark this success, a gala event was organised that witnessed participation from over hundred jumpers, locals, and the 'Dangal girls' -Fatima Shaikh and Sanya Malhotra, respectively.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [U.S.A.], Mar. 24 (ANI): Drinking a pint of ordinary beer, lager or two small pub measure (25 ml) of spirits a day may lower the risk of several, but not all, cardiovascular diseases, suggests a study.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Mar. 24 (ANI): Weight training, walking, hiking, jogging for 12 months may increase the particular hormone associated with bone growth, promoting bone formation, increasing bone density.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 24 (ANI): Ranking above HIV and malaria, health experts on the occasion of World Tuberculosis day, called for an increase in public awareness on the rising cases of TB among children.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 24 (ANI): Looking for extravagance but don't want to spend a bomb? Does your hunt for hotels always look for a perfect blend of comfort, luxury and budget? With the influx of 'budget brands' in the hotel segment, there has been an ignition of growth in the Hospitality sector, striking an increase in the number of in-bound vacations by 12 per cent.

Full Story >>

Saluting the spirit of acid-attack survivors

Updated: Mar 24, 2017 06:37 IST

Bengaluru [India], Mar. 24 (ANI): To celebrate the true spirit of womanhood, Housejoy's 'Joy Squad', in association with Atijeevan Foundation in Bengaluru and Chennai; brought joy into the lives of a few acid-attack survivors.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 23 (ANI): The Grand Venice, largest mall in Greater Noida and India's only mall built on the lines of Italian city of Venice, has recently launched its Ultimate Food Hub Terrazzo.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 23 (ANI): Shailyy- a born poetess, whose first story was published in Nandan at a tender age of 13 years, has many accolades to her credit.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 23 (ANI): India is in the midst of a digital transformation and fashion is at the forefront of this change.

Full Story >>

By Somdatta Saha

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar.22 (ANI): Universal Business School (UBS) has entered into a three year JV agreement with Tata Capital to train the Graduate Trainee participants, which Tata Capital recruits and cherry picks after a stringent selection process from the best campuses across the country. The program is fully residential and is held at the UBS campus in Karjat.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar.22 (ANI): Veteran photographer Raghu Rai was on Wednesday conferred with Lifetime Achievement Award at the 6th National Photography Awards.

Full Story >>

Durex gets into denims with Ranveer Singh

Updated: Mar 22, 2017 17:25 IST

New Delhi [India], Mar.22 (ANI): Durex is back again with Bollywood heartthrob, Ranveer Singh to announce the entry into Jeans.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Mar. 22 (ANI): According to a new University of Michigan study, researchers sought to explain how ethnic-racial identity exploration and resolution might affect friendship networks among youth in a diverse setting, as well as their peers over time.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar 22 (ANI): India's leading online fashion portal Jabong has announced the addition of American fashionwear brand Forever 21 to its product portfolio.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Mar.22 (ANI): Are you one of those who were asked to clear your academic doubts from teachers, rather than your peers? Well, you might want to give a thought about that now.

Full Story >>

Mumbai [India], Mar. 22 (ANI): Two Indian designers have been offered a global avenue to showcase their exquisite creations by 6Degree, India's fashion talent, and tech platform.

Full Story >>