Fri, Feb 24, 2017 | updated 11:39 AM IST

Moderately precise bids are persuasive: Research

Updated: Nov 11, 2016 15:12 IST

Washington D.C. (USA), Nov. 11 (ANI): Your attempt to make a precise offer for a car or a house will go in vain, if you are negotiating with some expertise in that area, according to research.

Results from a series of studies show that precise bids - for example, 9,572.36 dollars or 384,961.42 dollars - are more effective with novice negotiators, who tend to interpret higher precision as a sign of competence. Experts, on the other hand, found moderately precise bids to be most persuasive.

"Our research shows that more precise opening prices can yield you a significant negotiation advantage, but you have to know whom you're negotiating with," said researcher David D. Loschelder. "With amateurs, this number should be very precise; with experts, however, negotiators should either choose a moderate level of precision or back up their highly precise number with a compelling reason."

Loschelder became interested in the effects of precise numbers when he had to negotiate the price of a rental bicycle as a graduate student.

"The student who rented the bicycle to me asked for 34.50 euros for a period of four weeks. Not 30 euros, not 35 euros, not even 32 euros, but exactly 34.50 euros--a precise number that can't really be divided by four weeks," he explained. "As a consequence of this precision, I felt my counterpart was overly competent and I didn't even negotiate for a single cent."

Loschelder and colleagues speculated that there must be a limit to the effectiveness of precision, but their initial studies with amateur negotiators showed that very precise opening bids created surprisingly strong anchor points that shaped subsequent counteroffers and final deal terms. The researchers decided to examine the effects that such precision has in the context of real-world expertise.

In one experiment, 230 novice negotiators and 223 real-estate agents examined and evaluated a real-estate listing. Participants received the same pictures, floor plans, and other information, but the list prices they saw ranged from only two precise digits to eight precise digits. They were instructed to make a counteroffer in response to the list price and to state the highest price they would be willing to pay for the house.

The results showed that participants responded to precision differently depending on their expertise. Amateurs' counteroffers and maximum prices increased as the precision of the initial bid increased. The same was true for experts, but only up to around 5 precise digits; after this point, experts' counteroffers actually decreased as the list price became more precise.

Loschelder and colleagues found the same pattern of results when they asked novices and expert jewelers to evaluate a diamond necklace.

The researchers hypothesized that both amateurs and experts find highly precise bids to be unusual but they come to different conclusions as to why the seller made that particular bid.

"Interestingly, amateurs seem to think: 'Oh, this number is so precise, my opponent must have thought quite a bit about a fair price. He or she must be really competent,'" Loschelder explained. "In contrast, experts perceive this as too-precise a price and denigrate their opponent's competence."

Indeed, additional data indicated that perceived competence explained the responses of both amateur and expert participants. While amateurs saw more precise offers as a sign of a competent bidder, experts considered very precise bidders to be less competent than those who made moderately precise bids.

Interestingly, providing experts with a rationale for the bid seems to counteract the negative effect of precision. When car salespeople evaluated a very precise bid for a car that took various conditions - such as recent inspections, a small scratch, and long-distance usage - into account, they were willing to pay just as much as they would in response to a moderately precise bid. The results showed that including an explanation for a very precise bid made the seller appear more competent to the car experts.

Given that negotiations over things like a starting salary or the price of a house are an important part of everyday life, the findings have broad relevance:

"Whenever something is listed at a price, whenever someone opens a negotiation, price precision can come into play and you should pay close attention to your opponent's negotiation expertise," Loschelder concluded.

The study was published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. (ANI)

Washington D.C. [US], Feb. 24 (ANI): Parents, please take note! A study warns teenagers who self-report feeling drowsy during mid-afternoon, are 4.5 times more likely to commit violent crimes a decade and a half later.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 24 (ANI): A team of US researchers warn, fathers, who do cocaine at the time of conceiving a child, may be putting their son at risk of learning disabilities and memory loss.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 24 (ANI): Waring for all the sea food lovers! Consuming fish, rich in mercury may double the risk of developing motor neurone disease.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 23 (ANI): A two- day annual fest "POLITIA" was organised by political science department of Shyama Prasad Mukherjee college for Women, University of Delhi, on February 20 and 21.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 23 (ANI): The implementation of state laws for legalising same-sex marriage can significantly reduce the rate of suicide attempts among teenagers, reveals a study.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 22 (ANI): Beware to-be mothers! Listeria, a common food-borne bacterium, may pose a greater risk of miscarriage in the early stages of pregnancy than appreciated, warns a study.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 22 (ANI): Theatre is poetry! It's an amalgamation of music, dance and body language which takes the process of emoting to its peak. With the boom of visual digital media, theater had taken a backseat in terms of popularity.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 22 (ANI): In the day and age of months, sometimes years being spent planning the perfect wedding, reality is often a rude shock when the wedding is over and the marriage begins! This is because no one thinks of asking the questions that really matter!

Full Story >>

London [UK], Feb. 21 (ANI): Looks like Yo-Yo diet is not that bad!

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): As exams are just around the corner, many students would need to declutter their rooms and organise them in a better way so that they can focus only on their studies without getting distracted due to unmanaged stuff surrounding them.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 20 (ANI): After successful openings at their existing restaurants in Saket, Pacific Mall and Mall of India (Noida), Carl's Jr.®, the iconic American burger chain is now bringing its bigger and better California-style burgers to a prime location on the Gold Course Road, OHC (One Horizon Centre), Gurugram.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 20 (ANI): When every issue these days can be resolved with the help of your mobile phone, why can't parenting be too?

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 19 (ANI): In first of its kind, Broadcast Wearables has come up with a smart fitness t-shirt that can be used for navigation and keep an account of the steps you take, calories burnt and floors climbed.

Full Story >>

New Delhi (India), Feb. 19 (ANI): Referred as India's first original independent music startup, 'Friday Night Originals' has started with a vision to make original and independent music accessible to everyone.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb.19 (ANI): The Embassy of Germany, the German School and the Indo-German Chamber of Commerce (IGCC) will jointly host a two-day German Springfest at the German House here on February 25 and 26 this year.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 19 (ANI): Red Mango is launching a new dimension to healthy eating by introducing its new line of food called "ACTIVE FOOD" with an entire variety of value meals packed with natural ingredients made fresh at the cafes.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Feb. 19 (ANI): A team of US researchers finds that youth involved in drug dealing, alcohol use disorder and gang membership have higher mortality rates, especially from homicide by firearm.

Full Story >>

Women Safety Week - Men take a Stand

Updated: Feb 18, 2017 14:06 IST

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Prior to International Women's Day on March 8, a 'Women Safety Week', from February 19-24, is being organized by NGO SLAP (Street Level Awareness Program) and Priceless Possessions in Delhi and Agra, where men are taking a lead to raise a voice for gender equality & women safety.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Keeping the nerve of the city in mind- mixture of whole India- now get one stop store in the national capital, to cater to all your needs of fashion and design.

Full Story >>

By Somdatta Saha

Full Story >>