Wed, Mar 29, 2017 | updated 08:48 AM IST

India's official statistics on traffic deaths way too low

Updated: Jul 29, 2016 13:26 IST

Washington D.C, Jul 29 (ANI): Turns out, number of pedestrian and motorcycle deaths in India could be much higher than the official government data suggests.

Official government statistics on traffic deaths in southwest India significantly misrepresented the number of pedestrian and motorcycle deaths in the region over a two-year period, casting doubt on the reliability of that country's government data on traffic fatalities, a study led by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health suggests.

Researchers compared police reports in Belgaum, Karnataka, a district in southwest India with a population of 4.7 million, with statistics released by India's National Crime Records Bureau in 2013 and 2014.

The researchers found that the official statistics reported pedestrian deaths in the district as 9 percent of total traffic deaths versus 21 percent based on their review of the district's police reports. For motorcycle deaths, the national data reported that they made up 37 percent of traffic deaths while the researchers found the number was 49 percent.

"Our study suggests that taken together pedestrians and motorcyclists account for the vast majority of traffic deaths in India," said lead author Kavi Bhalla, adding: "The official national statistics for 2014 put the proportion at less than a third. The Indian government claims that they intend to cut traffic deaths by half, but this is impossible to achieve without knowing how people die on the roads."

Bhalla said the findings suggest that the Indian government could be misallocating its resources since it doesn't have a full picture of what is happening on the roads.

"These vulnerable groups need to be protected by providing appropriate infrastructure, such as sidewalks, raised crosswalks and segregated lanes," he noted. "However, the Indian government's highway spending has focused primarily on making roads wider and faster, and thus much more dangerous for these vulnerable groups."

Many experts familiar with road traffic injuries in India have long suspected that the national numbers were misreporting categories of traffic deaths, although the reasons for these discrepancies are not clear. As a result of their findings, study authors recommend that government statistics on road traffic deaths among different types of road users should not be used for research and policy decision-making.

While the study is based in only one district, the process of reporting in this district is similar to that used by all districts in the country. Using police reports, individual police stations produce summary tables of the crashes that occur within their jurisdictions. These tables are submitted to the District Crime Records Bureau, which, in turn, submits them to the National Crime Records Bureau. It is unclear how the numbers changed during this process.

The researchers noted that there wasn't a substantial discrepancy in the total traffic deaths between the official statistics for the district and their assessment. For example, in 2013, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 742 traffic fatalities in the Belgaum district while the district's records assessed by the research team suggest there were 759. This small difference - just two percent - reinforces the notion that the data issues seem to arise from misclassification.

They stated that the Indian government reported more than 140,000 traffic deaths in 2014, with pedestrians accounting for only five percent of the fatalities. This is unusually low for a country where walking is the most common means of transportation. In neighboring Bangladesh and Pakistan, pedestrians account for more than 40 percent of traffic deaths. Global estimates of countries with similar levels of economic development estimate that pedestrians account for 40 percent of all traffic fatalities.

As part of this study, the authors also reviewed the scientific literature on traffic fatalities in India that were based on population surveys, hospital reports and autopsies. On average, pedestrians comprised 30 percent of traffic deaths in these studies compared to 13 percent of traffic deaths in official tabulations for the same time period. Motorcycle riders comprised 36 percent of traffic deaths in other data sources, but only 20 percent in official reports.

The reasons for these apparent discrepancies in official statistics are not clear, the researchers say. One possibility is that official statistics capture the mode of transport for the person judged responsible for the crash rather than reporting how the person who died was traveling.

Whatever the cause, until reporting procedures are fixed, researchers and policymakers in India should use data from police case files not official government statistics, Bhalla said.

The study is published online in the journal Injury Prevention. (ANI)

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): The Delhi High Court will on Wednesday hear a plea filed by Vodafone India, alleging that the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) had failed to prohibit Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd's (RJIO) "blatant violation" of tariff orders, directions and regulations by permitting it to continue with its free offers.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): The Delhi High Court will on Wednesday pronounce its order in Swaraj Abhiyan's plea seeking allotment of common symbol to the party to contest the upcoming municipal elections in the national capital.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): The Supreme Court will on Wednesday a batch of petitions filed by several state governments seeking modification of its order banning liquor shops within 500 metres of State and National Highways across the country.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): In a unique gesture, Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan will on Wednesday present footballs to all MPs of both Houses of Parliament at a function near the Gandhi statue at Parliament.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): The Supreme Court on Wednesday will hear a plea filed by Himachal Pradesh Cricket Association (HPCA) chief and former BCCI president Anurag Thakur in connection with the allegations of encroaching land to construct the Dharamsala cricket stadium.

Full Story >>

Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): With Tamil Nadu farmers protesting in Delhi's Jantar Mantar for the past 15 days demanding drought relief package from the Centre, the Congress on Wednesday urged the government to consider the matter "urgently" and allocate money as demanded.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): After Air India cancelled Shiv Sena member Ravindra Gaikwad ticket post levying a travel ban, the Congress on Wednesday advised the beleaguered parliamentarian to tender an apology to the national carrier and put the matter to an end.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): As Jammu and Kashmir is again facing turbulence after three civilians were killed by the security forces during a stone pelting incident, defence expert Uday Bhaskar on Wednesday urged the Centre to chalk out a political solution to end the current crisis in the valley.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 29 (ANI): Kashmiri activist Sushil Pandit on Wednesday urged that Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti Government must not promote the idea of talks with separatist leaders.

Full Story >>

GST bill to be discussed in Lok Sabha today

Updated: Mar 29, 2017 06:45 IST

New Delhi [India],Mar 29 (ANI): The Lok Sabha will take up Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill for discussion and passage today.

Full Story >>

Mumbai [India],Mar 29 (ANI): The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Wednesday slammed Congress leader M.M. Hassan for his remarks against menstruating women and asked him to think before making such immature comments.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar 29 (ANI): In the wake of incidents of mass cheating being reported from Uttar Pradesh, Deputy Chief Minister Dinesh Sharma on Wednesday said that adequate steps are being taken to eradicate the 'nakal mafia' from the state.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar 29 (ANI): The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Wednesday said that the recently concluded encounter in Budgam district of Kashmir clearly depicts that supply of terrorists from across the border is continuing to disrupt the tranquility in the valley.

Full Story >>

Women activist demands counselling for Hassan

Updated: Mar 29, 2017 06:25 IST

New Delhi (India), Mar 29 (ANI): Women activist Ranjana Kumari on Wednesday asserted that Congress leader M.M.Hassan should be sent for counselling under a medical practitioner who could enlighten the politician that there is nothing pure or impure in regard with menstruation.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 28 (ANI): The government has listed the Goods and Services Tax Bill (GST) Bills in its agenda in the Lok Sabha for discussion and passage on Wednesday.

Full Story >>

Moradabad (Uttar Pradesh) [India], Mar. 28 (ANI): While Moradabad's non-vegetarian biryani is making itself famous abroad, its taste seems to be deteriorating in Uttar Pradesh.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Mar. 28 (ANI): A 21-year-old-woman and her friend were harassed by two police personnel today near Surajkund at Faridabad.

Full Story >>

Srinagar [India], Mar. 28 (ANI): In view of the volatile law and order situation in the Valley post the Budgam encounter, where stone pelting was also witnessed resulting in the death of three locals, Railway services will remain suspended throughout Kashmir tomorrow.

Full Story >>

Leh (Jammu and Kashmir) [India], Mar. 28 (ANI): The Leh Forest department on Tuesday carried out a mass plantation drive at Council Secretariat Leh, celebrating Forest Day to spread awareness among public for safeguarding the environment.

Full Story >>

Dantewada (Chhattisgarh) [India] Mar. 28 (ANI): The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has arrested an Office Superintendent working in the office of AEN, East Coast Railways in Chhattisgarh's Dantewada for demanding and accepting a bribe of Rs. 20,000 from the complainant.

Full Story >>