Sun, Jul 23, 2017 | updated 12:24 PM IST

Judicial push backed by legislative intent key to Indian politics reforming itself

Updated: Jan 05, 2017 13:38 IST      
Judicial push backed by legislative intent key to Indian politics reforming itself

By Shambhavi Ravishankar

New Delhi [India], Jan.5 (ANI): The New Year saw the Supreme Court of India passing a judgment that has genuine implications on the business of politics. A thorough reading of the judgments given by the 7 judges reveals some very interesting points of discussion. Two questions plagued the Justices: firstly, what method of legal interpretation should decide the scope and meaning of Section 123(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 ('the Act'); a literal or a purposive contextual interpretation. Secondly, what is the Constitutional position on the balancing of diverse interests with the secular nature of our polity?

Justice Madan B. Lokur (and Justice Rao and Justice Thakur), who represented the majority opinion, answered these questions after beautifully tracing the legislative history of the Act and the precedents under the same. The majority opined that a purposive interpretation was necessary keeping in mind "the social context of Section 123(3) and today's social and technological context" (Paragraph 46 of his judgment). He also stated that since S.123(3) was introduced as an amendment to the Act around the time that Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code was introduced (prohibition on promoting enmity between groups on various grounds), in Parliament all those years ago, they must be read together. It was the legislative intent to prevent "fissiparous, communal and separatist tendencies". (Para 28).

There was no fundamental right to be elected, and therefore Article 19's protection in the Constitution, had no bearing on a candidate. Candidacy was a special right that came with conditions of conduct. Justice S. A. Bobde, added on to this stating that Section 123(3) protected the entire transaction; the voter's right to vote and the candidate's pitch. (para 2 of his judgment). Any appeal made to an elector by a candidate/his agent on the ground of religion, race, caste, community, or language of either the candidate, his agent or the elector, amounts to a corrupt practice, was laid down.

Honourable Justices Goel, Lalit and Chandrachud, who dissented, brought out how secular discourse and politics did not automatically neglect the guarding of special interests based on the grounds listed above. The Constitution enshrined several protections to ameliorate people disadvantaged based on these grounds. Based on this, the dissenting judges believed that there was merit in continuing the judicial position that the law only prohibited a candidate from seeking votes based on his religion etc.

One issue with the judgment is the practical implications off "any appeal". When candidates make pitches to the people, the language and mediums they use will come under scrutiny so that it does not fall foul of this judgment. The Court remained silent on providing guidelines on how to determine this, stating that "it is a matter of evidence". Not providing some guiding principles or tests for determining whether language used will constitute an appeal on non-secular or divisive grounds, has left the matter not fully resolved, and open to re-litigation. The line between mere discussion and any appeal must be drawn.

There is truth the legal reasoning of all seven judges. Given how Indian politics has largely been a power protecting exercise, the question we must answer impartially is, have diverse interests been protected? Indian politics exemplifies what the Greek playwright Aristophanes wrote in the play "Knights", "to win the people, always cook them some savoury that pleases them."

No political party anywhere in India can claim that they are free from accusations of pandering to a stratum of voters. The two major ruling parties, BJP and the Congress, at various points in history, have had allegations of being pro - Hindutva or pro - Muslim levied against them.

In 2014, India recorded its highest voter turnout of 66.4%. One of the reasons for this was a desperate need in radical change in policy. This judgment is a big boost to the modern Indian voter, as well as a reminder that Indians irrespective of their background, have a lot of common interests in need of protecting: better infrastructure, a fairer tax regime, access to education, job opportunities, proper wages and working conditions, and accountability of the Government to name a few. MPs and MLAs should not be asked what they are being done for a given section, but what they are doing for Indians entirely. This judgment views the election process in entirety, and scrutinises the position of the voter. If we are truly to be a secular nation, our leaders must be elected through a secular mechanism. Gaining votes based on parameters such as religion, deviates attention on more essential questions of common development.

The multi-party system was adopted to represent the myriad interests in India. There are sections of society who have been denied basic human rights and their needs merit genuine representation and discussion. The judgment will have a positive implication on this if it is applied in good faith and in true sense of its wordings. It will motivate parties to speak policy to the people's who's interests it seeks to represent. It will dissuade parties from asking people for votes based on fear of being marginalised. The judgment could change the political dialogue of the country.

Religion and language should be deeply personal and should not determine how people interact with one another. The concept of caste and community discrimination should hold no value in social interaction. An election is not about the candidate alone. It is about the vision the candidate has for his given constituency and the needs of the voters (who are of different backgrounds) in that constituency. Without a judicial push backed by legislative intent of this kind, politics will never reform itself.

This is not an idealistic fancy or wish. This is a legitimate issue that plagues our Governance structures today. To have free and fair elections, parties cannot be allowed to divide the electorate. (ANI)

Srinagar [India], July. 23 (ANI): A terrorist has been gunned down as the Indian Army on Sunday foiled an infiltration bid at Machhal Sector along the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir.

Full Story >>

Srinagar (Jammu and Kashmir) [India], July 23 (ANI): A base camp hospital in Baltal of Jammu and Kashmir's Sonmarg district has provided medical facilities to Amarnath yatra pilgrims.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): A day after the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) came out with reports slamming the Railways for serving food which they deemed to be unfit for consumption, the Ministry of Railways, on Sunday, highlighted their New Catering Policy with an objective to provide quality food to passengers.

Full Story >>

Delhi: Mayawati to meet BSP leaders over future strategy

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 11:04 IST     

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) Supremo Mayawati on Sunday is set to meet the MPs, MLAs and all senior leaders of the party in the national capital today, to chalk out the party's future plans.

Full Story >>

BJD Donation row: BJP, Congress demand impartial enquiry

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 10:54 IST     

Bhubaneswar (Odisha), July 23(ANI): Following reports emerging of the Biju Janata Dal (BJD) receiving huge cash donations from anonymous sources in a dubious manner, leader of the Opposition in the Odisha Assembly Narasingha Mishra on Sunday dubbed it as a clear case of 'corruption' and demanded an impartial enquiry into the matter.

Full Story >>

UP: 21 admitted after consuming 'poisonous' tea in Mirzapur

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 10:18 IST     

Mirzapur (Uttar Pradesh) [India], July 23 (ANI): At least 21 people fell ill after consuming poisonous tea from a tea stall in Uttar Pradesh's Mirzapur district.

Full Story >>

JD (U) condemns no tarmac access for Lalu at Patna airport

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 10:08 IST     

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): With the Centre scrapping direct access for Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) supremo Lalu Prasad Yadav and his wife Rabri Devi's to Patna Airport tarmac, the Janata Dal (United) on Sunday condemned the incident and said rules and regulations should be same for all former chief ministers.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): The Janata Dal (United) on Sunday said the meeting between Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar and Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi was held to call on the Grand Alliance to maintain its strength and unity.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Sunday said that the withdrawal of tarmac access for Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) supremo Lalu Prasad Yadav and his wife Rabri Devi is a welcome sign, as it gives out a message that there is no space for VVIP culture in a democracy.

Full Story >>

Kolkata (West Bengal) [India], July 23(ANI): With Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar meeting Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi yesterday, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Sunday downplayed the rendezvous saying no amount of meeting can help counter the 'Modi wave' sweeping the nation.

Full Story >>

UP: Lightning kills nine, CM Yogi announces ex-gratia

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 09:13 IST     

Lucknow (Uttar Pradesh) [India], July 23 (ANI): Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has announced a compensation of Rs. four lakhs each to the families of the nine deceased, killed due to lightning in different parts of the state.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 23 (ANI): Prime Minister Narendra Modi hosted a farewell dinner for outgoing President Pranab Mukherjee on Saturday.

Full Story >>

Indore: Vendors deploy armed guards to protect tomatoes!

Updated: Jul 23, 2017 09:12 IST     

Indore (Madhya Pradesh) [India], July 23 (ANI): With tomato prices' skyrocketing, it has become important in the whole sale vegetable market of Madhya Pradesh's Indore city, to guard the pricey vegetable.

Full Story >>

Bareilly (Uttar Pradesh) [India], July 22 (ANI): As many as 24 Kawariyas, four Indo Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) personnel and two police personnel were injured after a community pelted stones on the group of devotees of Lord Shiva in the Khallam village of Aliganj Thana region here.

Full Story >>

Puducherry [India], July 22 (ANI): The counselling for admission to MBBS through the government-run Centralised Admission Committee (CENTAC) was conducted on Saturday.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 22 (ANI): Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar met Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi at the latter's residence here on Saturday, in the backdrop of clouds of uncertainity hovering over the 'mahagathbandhan' in Bihar.

Full Story >>

Thiruvananthapuram (Kerala) [India], July 22 (ANI): Kerala Congress MLA M. Vincent, who was arrested on charges of rape, stalking and abetment of suicide of a 51-year-old woman, has blamed the Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPM) for the indictment.

Full Story >>

AIU intercepts person with Narcotics kit at Mumbai airport

Updated: Jul 22, 2017 22:57 IST     

Mumbai (Maharashtra) [India], July 22 (ANI): Air Intelligence Unit (AIU) officers on Saturday intercepted a person over seizure of a Narcotics kit worth Rs. 2 crore at the Mumbai Airport.

Full Story >>

New Delhi[India], July 22 (ANI): Priya Singh Paul, who claims to be the biological daughter of late Congress leader Sanjay Gandhi, has filed a writ petition at the Bombay High Court against the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) and the makers of 'Indu Sarkar' to put a stay on the release of Madhur Bhandarkar's upcoming film.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], July 22 (ANI): Delhi's Patiala House Court on Saturday directed the Economic Offence Wing (EOW) of the Delhi Police to register an FIR against Star India Pvt. Ltd. (SIPL) and some of its top officials with others on a cheating complaint filed by Delhi-based Noida Software Technology Park Ltd (NSTPL).

Full Story >>