Mon, Feb 20, 2017 | updated 11:46 AM IST

ASSOCHAM team meets revenue secretary on draft GST legislation

Updated: Aug 19, 2016 13:17 IST
New Delhi, Aug.19 (ANI): An ASSOCHAM delegation, including Anita Rastogi Partner-Indirect Tax, PricewaterhouseCoopers Private Limited, Shiva Nagesh AVP, DLF Ltd, Mr. T G Ramakrishnan Consultant, Indirect Taxation, Hindustan Unilever Ltd and Sujit Ghosh Partner and National Head, Advaita Legal had a meeting with Dr. Hasmukh Adhia, Revenue Secretary, Ministry of Finance for consideration under the draft GST legislation in New Delhi today.

Fundamental issues concerning Constitutional Amendment Bill on the draft GST legislation were raised during the meeting. They included the following:

a) Goods and Services both defined under the Constitution and CAB respectively. Is it therefore possible/ appropriate to carve out a separate definition of these terms in the operative legislation in derogation of the Constitution. Example - software.

b) Fate of GST on sale and consumption of electricity. While Entry 53 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India has not been deleted by the CAB, there is no restrictive covenant under the CAB seeking to exclude levy of GST on electricity unlike in the case of alcohol, petroleum products. Contrary to this, the Central Government's view before Rajya Sabha Select Committee on GST indicates that inclusion of electricity is not envisaged in GST. Non-inclusion of electricity will lead to significant economic distortions.

c) Petroleum Industry will operate under hybrid tax regime and inability to claim GST credit due to temporary non-inclusion of five petro products could shore up costs. Similar would be the fate of alcohol industry. Consequently, some thinking around zero rating or concessional taxation under existing law on the inputs for these industries is warranted.

d) GST Council to provide 'mechanism' to resolve disputes. The word mechanism connotes procedures. If there is an infraction between two constitutional bodies, whether jurisdictional issues in such situation presently covered under Article 131 will be subservient to mechanism adopted by the GST Council.

e) Entry 92A and 92B of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution is retained, i.e. taxes on inter-state trade retained under the Constitution of India. Moreover, the Central Sales Tax, 1956 has not been repealed. Thus, it appears that the Centre continues to have the power to levy CST on inter-State sales. Is it an oversight? Same issue arises with regard to Article 366(29A).

The delegation also sought information and explanation of the definition and operative Issues related to the bill. They included:

a) The charging section (Section 7 of CGST law and Section 4 of IGST law) is deficient in as much as there is no reference to levy being on 'value'.

b) 'Location of supplier of goods' and 'location of recipient of goods' not defined.

c) 'Location of supplier of service' and 'location of recipient of service' needs to be relooked at in the context of practical difficulties in attributing locations directly concerned with provision/ receipt of services.

d) Intra-state and inter-State not defined in the CGST draft law.

e) No provisions dealing with supplies to SEZ. Consequential amendments needed in the SEZ Act.

On adjudication of disputes, the following issues were discussed:

a) No limitation period for issuance of show cause notice.

b) Composition of AAR and the unnecessary second appeal needs to be relooked at.

The delegation also raised issues related to the real estate sector, which included the following:

a) Input Tax Credit is not available for inputs/ input services utilised in the construction of immovable property. Tax paid on inputs/ input services would become a cost for the builders, etc.

b) The Draft Legislation does not provide for the abatement of the value of land for levy of GST.

c) Need clarity on the taxability of the development rights under the Draft GST Legislation.

Issues under valuation were also discussed and included:

a) The Draft GST Legislation provides that transaction value would include all taxes other than CGST, SGST and IGST. This would lead to tax on tax scenario. To avoid tax cascading, transaction value should be valued net of any taxes.

b) Currently 'transaction value' includes subsidies. Therefore, subsides/refunds/incentives provided under State Industrial Polices, Area based incentives as well as FTP may be included in the transaction value.

c) 'Stock transfer' - It is suggested that for the purpose of valuation of stock transfer, the method should be simple and consistent with accounting method of the Company. It would create considerable compliance difficulties if a company has to maintain extensive records to defend or substantiate the valuation used for paying tax on stock transfers.

d) Clear Valuation mechanism should be provided for taxation of FOC supplies.

The other issues raised included:

a) Definition of input service distributor enables distribution of credit of only input services by the ISD. The definition of ISD should be amended to enable the ISD to distribute credit of inputs as well. (ANI)

New Delhi [India], Feb. 19 (ANI): CAclubindia's Goods and Services Tax (GST) app became the number one app on GST on Google Play Store, with a successful 85,000 plus downloads within a month's time, scoring an average of 4.4 rating by over 700 users.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 19 (ANI): Indian food processing sector has the potential to attract USD 33 billion of investment and create nine million jobs by FY 2024, revealed an ASSOCHAM-Grant Thorton Research paper.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 19 (ANI): ONE Co.Work, the end-to-end co-working space provider, announced the launch of its Gurugram-based co-working office on Saturday. The event received a phenomenal response from the start-up community, investors, freelancers, and bloggers, and was also attended by several industry veterans.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Khadi and Village Industries Commission (KVIC) which has, in the last six months, bagged large orders from several public and private sector companies since the Narendra Modi government came to power, has bagged the largest ever order from the Ministry Of Health on February 16, 2017.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI-BusinessWire India): Working towards its vision of enhancing the employability of youth by skill development, CMC Skills Pvt. Ltd. in consortium with Mitcon Consultancy Services Limited was recently selected by Jharkhand Skill Development Mission to Establish and Operate Mega Skill Development Centre in Jharkhand on PPP mode.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): The 10th council meeting of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) to vet the draft supporting legislations crucial for its implementation has begun at Udaipur here today.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 18 (ANI): Delay in resumption of imports by Iran is likely to hinder the recovery in Indian Basmati rice exports, says credit rating agency, ICRA, in its latest update note on Indian Basmati rice industry.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): Spice Digital Limited, a part of Spice Mobility group has joined hands with MoMagic Technologies to introduce a new product named 'AdGyde'. AdGyde is a real time, mobile App Analytics and Attribution Solution for the App developers and marketers.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI-NewsVoir): The State Government of Victoria hosted a delegation of India's leading Creative Industries for the first time in Melbourne from the 14th 16th of February. The delegation explored business opportunities against the backdrop of the inaugural Asia-Pacific Triennial of Performing Arts (Asia TOPA).

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on Friday

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI): State Bank of India (SBI) on Friday played host to senior commercial bankers from Egypt at a Strategic Training Unit (STU) organized for the Egyptian bankers who were in India on a study tour on MSME units in the country.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI-NewsVoir): CA Technologies today announced it has appointed iValue InfoSolutions as a Value Added Distributor (VAD) for India and the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) region to grow the mid-market segment and address customers' needs in their digital transformation journey.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI-NewsVoir): LexisNexis® India (, a leading provider of content and technology solutions, and Legasis Services Private Limited, a provider of integrated legal and information technology solutions specializing in the compliance domain for corporates, announced the launch of Enterprise Compliance Management Module for Ecommerce, Pharmaceuticals and IT/ITESin its Lexis®Practical Guidance portfolio. Lexis® Practical Guidance's Enterprise Compliance Management module is an incredible risk and compliance tool kit designed to help legal professionals in different industries. With clear, concise notes written by leading experts in compliance, spelling out exactly what needs to be done in practical terms, the module provides all sorts of forms, checklists, templates, precedents, policies, registers and examples that are required by any legal professional for compliance management right, and always in line with the latest changes in the law and the marketplace.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI-BusinessWire India): RICS has launched Emerging Leaders Program (ELP) - a one-year executive program designed for mid-career to senior professionals in the real estate, construction, and infrastructure sector.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI): Citizen engagement platform LocalCircles , via a survey, revealed that out of the 8, 715 participants, 68 percent said that majority of their transactions are now happening in cash. Only 32 percent said that they still prefer using debit or credit cards as well as other forms of digital transactions to make payments.

Full Story >>

Somany upgrades its mobile app in offline mode

Updated: Feb 17, 2017 15:05 IST

New Delhi [India], Feb. 17 (ANI-BusinessWire India): Somany Ceramics, a leading brand in the Tiles, Sanitaryware and Bath Fittings industry has recently upgraded its mobile app, enabling customers to browse content even in its offline mode. The app is a one-stop destination for users who are interested in tiles, sanitary ware, bath fittings and other ancillary products.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): Credit rating agency ICRA on Friday estimated that the gross market borrowings of the state governments is supposed to rise from Rs. 3.7 trillion in FY2017 to Rs. 4.5 trillion in FY2018, which would exert an upward pressure on state development loans (SDL) yields in FY2018.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): The government needs to continuously invest in improving the ease of doing business environment, develop sound infrastructure, and ensure availability of trained workforce as India is set on a growth trajectory that promises all-round development, economic welfare and strong macro-economic indicators, noted a recent ASSOCHAM-EY report.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): One of the largest retail chains based out of the Middle East has recently signed up with LogiNext, to enable the tracking and optimization of the movements of their 1,000+ on-field employees. LogiNext is the fastest growing SaaS company in the field of logistics and field workforce management and it has now opened up its cloud-based software to all the companies with large on-field workforce across the world.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 17 (ANI): Cyber-security company F-Secure has acquired privately-held company Inverse Path, an industry leader in providing security services to the avionics, automotive, and industrial control sectors.

Full Story >>