Wed, Feb 22, 2017 | updated 03:04 AM IST

New paper says excessive skepticism towards harm reduction technologies by FCTC is worrying

Updated: Sep 17, 2016 12:49 IST

New Delhi [India], Sept.17 (ANI-Businesswire India): A new paper published by Reason Foundation, a US-based think tank, finds that the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) has been overly skeptical of technologies that many believe have the potential to reduce the harm done by tobacco use.

Underlying this skepticism is a lack of openness and transparency that puts the FCTC well outside the norms established by other UN bodies. The paper suggests that there is a need for the FCTC to reform its processes to enable greater participation and transparency - including by allowing journalists to observe all meetings.

The paper, authored by Julian Morris, vice president of research at Reason Foundation, notes that since the FCTC came into force in 2005, the number of smokers in the world has increased, mainly in China and other countries that were the FCTC's primary target. As Morris comments, "The FCTC has not been a stellar success on its own terms."

Morris argues that a key problem with the FCTC is that it is beholden to the idea that the only way to reduce smoking is for smokers to "quit or die." It is thus highly sceptical of the potential for new technologies, such as vape devices (also known as "electronic cigarettes"), to reduce smoking-related harms. Among other evidence, Morris cites a report released last week by the FCTC, commissioned in secret from unknown authors that refers to unpublished evidence from meetings held in secret, which advocates that vape products should be heavily regulated.

Yet, a recent report from the Royal College of Physicians concluded that vaping is "at least 95 percent safer" than smoking, that vape devices should be widely available and that doctors should encourage smokers to use them instead of smoking. Moreover, millions of people have already stopped smoking by using vape products. And where vape products are legally available, rates of smoking initiation have fallen faster than in locations where they are not available.

If governments follow the FCTC's advice, vape products would become less readily available and more people will smoke, with far worse health consequences. "The WHO's opposition to tobacco harm reduction is dishonest and threatens public health," Morris says.

Morris suggests that many of the problems with the FCTC stem from the fact that it violates all the precepts of good governance - especially transparency. He notes that at the two most recent Conferences of the Parties (COPs) of the FCTC, in Seoul in 2012, and in Moscow in 2014, all journalists were thrown out of the public gallery and the meetings were held in secret.

The FCTC also excludes many groups whose input would be highly relevant. Morris notes:

"The FCTC currently lists only 20 NGOs as Observers on its website. By contrast, the Framework Convention on Climate Change lists over 2,000 NGOs as Observers. Moreover, there is essentially no participation by representatives of many affected groups, including users of tobacco and vape products, vendors, and farmers. Participation by IGOs has also been restricted; even Interpol has been denied Observer status despite its expertise in combating illicit trade in tobacco, a key topic covered by the Convention."

The primary justification the FCTC Secretariat gives for restricting participation and operating in secret is the avoidance of conflicts of interest. But the real reason, Morris argues, is that the FCTC doesn't want to allow anyone into the tent who disagrees with its assumption that the only option for smokers is to "quit or die." As Morris observes:

"If the FCTC is genuinely committed to the 'right to health' then it must listen to those who are taking control of the things that determine their health - and to those who are helping them to do so. In other words, it should open itself up to participation by groups representing vapers, snus users, and companies producing these and other less harmful nicotine-containing products."

Meanwhile, to address genuine conflicts of interest, Morris suggests that the FCTC should "open itself up to scrutiny. That means, at the very least, permitting journalists to attend all sessions of COPs and technical committees. Better yet, the FCTC might live stream all its proceedings over the web." (ANI-Businesswire India)

New Delhi [India], Feb.21 (ANI): Infomark Korea, a company with a global reputation for manufacturing 3G/4G mobile communication devices as well as wearable products is finalising a partnership with BSNL for production of WiMax mobile routers in the Kerala telecom circle.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI):The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) has asked all chairs and missions to to promote Ayush and Ayurveda, said Minister of State for External Affairs, General V.K. Singh (Retd), at an ASSOCHAM event held in New Delhi today.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb.21 (ANI):Louis Taylor, Chief Executive Officer of UK Export Finance (UKEF), is visiting India from 20-23 February. UKEF, the UK's Export Credit Agency, has up to £1 billion in capacity to provide finance to support Indian buyers of British goods, services and intangibles, with support available in Indian Rupees.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI-BusinessWire India): Herbalife, a global nutrition company, announced its partnership with Special Olympics Bharat (SOB) to support and encourage athletes with intellectual disabilities in India.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): After his appointment as the Chairman earlier today, Natarajan Chandrasekaran chaired his first Board Meeting of Tata Sons Limited.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 21 (ANI): Reliance Industries chairman and managing director Mukesh Ambani on Tuesday announced that Reliance Jio, which has achieved unprecedented level of acceptance in the world, has crossed a subscriber base of 100million in record time.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI-BusinessWireIndia): HCL Infosystems, one of India's Premier IT Services, Distribution and Digital Solutions Company, showcased Cloud and Internet-of-Things (IoT) based solutions at the Future Decoded, Microsoft India's flagship conference, being held in Mumbai on February 21 and 22, 2017.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 21 (ANI): Addressing the media on the progress in making Digital Payments a mass movement in India, CEO Niti Aayog Amitabh Kant said that there are nearly 10 lakh citizens who have so far got reward money of over Rs. 153.5 crore for embracing digital payments.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): In the wake of the ongoing BMC Polls in Mumbai, Niranjan Hiranandani, CMD, Hiranandani Communities has encouraged Mumbaikars to exercise their voting rights and feel proud of their city.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): India's first healthcare education and training company, Vivo Healthcare is eyeing major expansion across India, South Asia and the Middle East, following fresh strategic funding from Netherlands-based ICCO Investments.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 21 (ANI-BusinessWireIndia): Eminent educationist and psychologist has been bestowed the BBC Knowledge Award for Outstanding Contribution to education at the World Education Awards at Taj Lands End in Bandra by the Minister of Education of Malaysia on 18th February for his mass movement to reduce dropouts and girl education.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): Siemens Limited and Siemens Rail Automation Ltd. S.A.U Spain have jointly won an order worth Rs. 287 crore to supply state-of-the-art signaling technology for the first two metro lines of the Nagpur Metro, the North-South and the East-West Corridors.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 21 (ANI-NewsVoir): Samsung, Apple and HTC have emerged as the most successful mobile brands in the first decade of smartphones in India, according to the Mobile Industry Consumer Insight (MICI) Report by CyberMedia (CMR) Research.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb 21 (ANI): To commemorate the 25th year of the ASEAN India relations, TEPC (Telecom Equipment and Services Export Promotion Council) organized an inter-ministerial meeting between telecom ministers of ASEAN countries and India in New Delhi today.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): The most anticipated Goods and Services Tax (GST) bill, which is most likely to be a game-changer in terms of cost cutting will provide leverage to implement cost cutting mechanisms, thus paving way for consumers to avail Gensets at lower costs, said Sanjeev Nimkar, Vice President, Business Head Kirloskar Oil Engines Ltd., at the launch of their new range of High Horsepower (HHP) Gensets.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): After relentless debates have been underway discussing the impact of demonetisation, HDFC Bank Chairman Deepak Parekh on Tuesday stated that it is high time this discussion ended, while casting his vote in Mumbai today in the BMC polls.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): Known for its diverse publishing programmes across different disciplines, Oxford University Press (OUP) introduced its medical publishing programme to India.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): Excelity Global, India's largest provider of payroll administration, benefits and human capital management, announced its collaboration with Fortis Healthcare, on Monday.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 21 (ANI): IT solutions provider Infosys retaliated against allegations made in the anonymous whistleblower's letter that was published in newspapers on Monday, stating that the assertions made are libellous and are aimed at tarnishing the image of Infosys and its management.

Full Story >>

Mumbai [India], Feb. 20 (ANI): Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) Ltd on Monday appointed V. Ramakrishnan as the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of the company.

Full Story >>