Tue, Feb 28, 2017 | updated 04:09 AM IST

Panamagate: Pak SC unhappy with PTI's arguments

Updated: Nov 18, 2016 15:49 IST

Islamabad [Pakistan], Nov. 18 (ANI): Unimpressed with the arguments of Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) counsel Hamid Khan in the Panamagate scandal accusing Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his children of laundering money to purchase their London properties, the Supreme Court has asked the former to build his case and not politick.

It was not as expected by the PTI when their senior counsel opened his arguments yesterday before the five-judge apex court bench hearing the Panamagate case. The counsel quoted at length from three speeches made by Sharif - on April 5, April 22 and May 16 - to proclaim his innocence before the nation, reports the Dawn.

To this, Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed observed that "instead of going into mind-numbing rhetoric, the counsel should have relied on the documents submitted by the Prime Minister and his family members", adding that Khan's case should be that the documents the respondents are relying on were wrong.

"Please focus on the [case] at hand," Justice Saeed advised the petitioner's counsel, adding that the court could not draw any conclusion on the basis of the Prime Minister's speeches.

Justice Saeed also expressed his apprehension at the way the proceedings were going in this case and said that this hearing would likely continue until 2099.

When the counsel pointed out that Sharif had promised the nation he would quit if found guilty, Justice .Khosa reminded Khan that the Prime Minister had made that promise with himself, not with the counsel.

The PTI's lawyer also lamented that the speeches failed to offer any explanation of how the Sharifs generated the capital to install factories in Dubai when they had gone broke after the nationalisation of their industries nor did they explain where the family found the money to revive sick industrial units that were handed over to them in 1983.

The court, more interested in the matter at hand, nudged the counsel in the direction of a financial investigation report carried out by an agency in the British Virgin Islands in 1999 for the Al-Taufiq case, where a suspicious activity report had also been generated.

At one point, when the counsel contested the Prime Minister's claims regarding the payment of Rs. 360 million in tax, Justice Khosa observed that it was not the court's job to scrutinise the entire life of a person. The judge said that the matter of paying taxes was irrelevant to the case at hand and asked the counsel to focus his arguments on the London properties.

The Chief Justice also emphasized that in criminal trials, the benefit of the doubt always went in the favour of the suspect, adding that the counsel's arguments were not a substitute for tangible proof.

"We are giving you the chance to address the court for the sake of our satisfaction, but after hearing you for over an hour, we are still at the same position," the bench observed.

"On the basis of your arguments and replies filed, it seems [the case] is not so simple that we may straightaway come to a definite conclusion and pass an order unless there is a detailed inquiry within a solid time frame, conducted by an inquiry commission headed by a Supreme Court judge," the bench said.

At one point, Justice Khosa even quipped it appeared that the judges were more prepared than the lawyers in the case, especially since an elected Prime Minister was in the dock.

The apex court will resume hearing in the Panamagate matter on November 30. (ANI)

Astana [Kazakhstan], Feb. 28 (ANI): Russian President Vladimir Putin has affirmed his willingness to cooperate with Tajikistan in strengthening security and stability.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 28 (ANI): Former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has urged President Donald Trump to speak out against hate crimes following a rise of the same across the country.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [United States], Feb. 28 (ANI): U.S. President Donald Trump has said that nobody knew health care could be so complicated, adding that his administration has come up with a solution which is very good.

Full Story >>

New York [U.S.], Feb. 27 (ANI): The White House announced Monday that President Donald Trump's first budget proposal will look to increase defence and security spending by $54 billion and cut roughly the same amount from non-defence programs.

Full Story >>

Militants behead German hostage in Philippines

Updated: Feb 27, 2017 22:01 IST

New York [U.S.], Feb. 27 (ANI): Abu Sayyaf militants in southern Philippines beheaded a German hostage after the deadline passed to pay his ransom passed.

Full Story >>

London [UK], Feb. 27 (ANI): The indigenous communities in Pakistan's Sindh province have come down on the government over the massive coal mining in the region which has severely affected their daily lives.

Full Story >>

Kabul [Afghanistan], Feb.27 (ANI): The killing of five UAE diplomats in a terror attack in Kandahar was planned in Pakistan, a spokesman of Afghanistan's interior ministry has said.

Full Story >>

Senior Taliban commander killed in Afghanistan

Updated: Feb 27, 2017 18:11 IST

Islamabad [Pakistan], Feb.27 (ANI): The Taliban confirmed on Monday through a statement that one of its senior commanders had been killed in an air strike in Afghanistan's northern Kunduz province.

Full Story >>

Karachi (Sindh) [Pakistan): Sufism is the country's first line of defence against terrorism, said PPP Chairmain Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on Monday.

Full Story >>

Karachi [Pakistan], Feb.27 (ANI): Police in Karachi were Monday directed by an anti-terrorism court (ATC) to put the names of Muttahida Quami Movement (MQM) leaders Farooq Sattar, Khalid Maqbool and Amir Liaquat on the Exit Control List (ECL).

Full Story >>

Lahore [Pakistan], Feb.27 (ANI): Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) has issued show-cause notices to a pilot and two others officials for loading seven extra passengers on a Karachi-Medina flight last month in a violation of air safety regulations.

Full Story >>

Rawalpindi [Pakistan], Feb.27 (ANI): Pakistan security forces have covered the further arrest of 91 suspects from across the country under the Operation Radd-ul-Fasaad counter-terrorism operations.

Full Story >>

Karachi (Sindh) [Pakistan], Feb.27 (ANI): The Governor of Pakistan's Sindh province, Muhammad Zubair, has said that both Pakistan and China will stand to benefit from the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) in both the short and long term.

Full Story >>

New Delhi, Feb. 27 (ANI): At least seven people were killed in an attack on a prison bus in Colombo, according to local media reports.

Full Story >>

London [UK], Feb. 27(ANI): The Baloch Cultural Association (BCA) held a conference at Birkbeck University in London.

Full Story >>

Berlin [Germany], Feb.27 (ANI): The Embassy of India, Berlin organized second Diaspora event over the weekend at the embassy in which several Indian associations and prominent members of Diaspora, besides representatives of 16 student associations participated.

Full Story >>

Kathmandu [India], Feb. 27(ANI): The National Seismological Centre (NSC) of Nepal recorded two aftershocks post the Gorkha region earthquake on Monday.

Full Story >>

Hong Kong [China], Feb. 27(ANI): All may not be well between the 'all weather friends' Pakistan and China.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], Feb. 27(ANI): As Mahershala Ali became the first Muslim actor to win Oscar for his role in Hollywood flick 'Moonlight', Pakistan's Representative to the United Nations Maleeha Lodhi tweeted in support of his achievement.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C.[USA], Feb. 27(ANI): Hijab-wearing ex-White House Muslim staffer of Bangladeshi-origin has said that she quit her job after U.S. President Donald Trump announced his controversial travel ban, which made her last for eight days in the new administration.

Full Story >>