Thu, Apr 27, 2017 | updated 01:07 AM IST

Panamagate: Pak SC unhappy with PTI's arguments

Updated: Nov 18, 2016 15:49 IST      
Panamagate: Pak SC unhappy with PTI's arguments

Islamabad [Pakistan], Nov. 18 (ANI): Unimpressed with the arguments of Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) counsel Hamid Khan in the Panamagate scandal accusing Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and his children of laundering money to purchase their London properties, the Supreme Court has asked the former to build his case and not politick.

It was not as expected by the PTI when their senior counsel opened his arguments yesterday before the five-judge apex court bench hearing the Panamagate case. The counsel quoted at length from three speeches made by Sharif - on April 5, April 22 and May 16 - to proclaim his innocence before the nation, reports the Dawn.

To this, Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed observed that "instead of going into mind-numbing rhetoric, the counsel should have relied on the documents submitted by the Prime Minister and his family members", adding that Khan's case should be that the documents the respondents are relying on were wrong.

"Please focus on the [case] at hand," Justice Saeed advised the petitioner's counsel, adding that the court could not draw any conclusion on the basis of the Prime Minister's speeches.

Justice Saeed also expressed his apprehension at the way the proceedings were going in this case and said that this hearing would likely continue until 2099.

When the counsel pointed out that Sharif had promised the nation he would quit if found guilty, Justice .Khosa reminded Khan that the Prime Minister had made that promise with himself, not with the counsel.

The PTI's lawyer also lamented that the speeches failed to offer any explanation of how the Sharifs generated the capital to install factories in Dubai when they had gone broke after the nationalisation of their industries nor did they explain where the family found the money to revive sick industrial units that were handed over to them in 1983.

The court, more interested in the matter at hand, nudged the counsel in the direction of a financial investigation report carried out by an agency in the British Virgin Islands in 1999 for the Al-Taufiq case, where a suspicious activity report had also been generated.

At one point, when the counsel contested the Prime Minister's claims regarding the payment of Rs. 360 million in tax, Justice Khosa observed that it was not the court's job to scrutinise the entire life of a person. The judge said that the matter of paying taxes was irrelevant to the case at hand and asked the counsel to focus his arguments on the London properties.

The Chief Justice also emphasized that in criminal trials, the benefit of the doubt always went in the favour of the suspect, adding that the counsel's arguments were not a substitute for tangible proof.

"We are giving you the chance to address the court for the sake of our satisfaction, but after hearing you for over an hour, we are still at the same position," the bench observed.

"On the basis of your arguments and replies filed, it seems [the case] is not so simple that we may straightaway come to a definite conclusion and pass an order unless there is a detailed inquiry within a solid time frame, conducted by an inquiry commission headed by a Supreme Court judge," the bench said.

At one point, Justice Khosa even quipped it appeared that the judges were more prepared than the lawyers in the case, especially since an elected Prime Minister was in the dock.

The apex court will resume hearing in the Panamagate matter on November 30. (ANI)

London [U.K.], April 26 (ANI): France has said that it has evidence that the Bashar-Al-Assad-led Syrian Government was responsible for the chemical attack that killed 89 people.

Full Story >>

Pak origin Canadian Senator robbed in Islamabad

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 21:40 IST     

Islamabad [Pakistan], April 26 (ANI): A Canadian Senator of Pakistani origin was allegedly robbed in Islamabad. The police have lodged a complaint against two unidentified men.

Full Story >>

Ansari leaves for Poland after concluding visit to Armenia

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 21:16 IST     

Yeravan [Armenia],Apr 26 (ANI):Vice President Hamid Ansari left for Poland for the second and final leg of his two-nation visit after concluding his three-day trip to Armenia on Wednesday.

Full Story >>

Moscow (Russia), Apr 26 (ANI): Indian Finance Minister Arun Jaitley has said that the diplomatic relation between India and Russia goes far beyond just the relations between the governments, adding that this relationship will continue to grow with the current level of engagement.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], April 26 (ANI): Unhappy with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit order against his policies on travel ban and sanctuary cities, President Donald Trump on Wednesday vowed to fight against the order in the Supreme Court.

Full Story >>

Nepal opposition obstructs parliament proceedings

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 19:21 IST     

Kathmandu [Nepal], April 26 (ANI): Nepal's main opposition party, the CPN-UML (Communist Party of Nepal- Unified Marxist Leninist), continued to stall proceedings in parliament for the second consecutive day on Wednesday in protest against the government's decision to increase the number of local levels in 11 districts.

Full Story >>

Dalian [China], April 26 (ANI): China on Wednesday launched its second aircraft carrier and, the first to be developed and built indigenously from the Dalian shipyard in Liaoning Province.

Full Story >>

Pak denies India consular access to Jadhav again

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 18:27 IST     

Islamabad [Pakistan], April 26 (ANI): Pakistan on Wednesday again denied India consular access to former Indian naval officer Kulbhushan Jadhav who was awarded a death sentence by Islamabad military court for alleged espionage activities.

Full Story >>

Yerevan (Armenia), Apr 26 (ANI): Vice President of India M. Hamid Ansari has said that the countries that have invested in educating their populations, built strong consumer economies, and have democratic institutions that can deal with social change will benefit.

Full Story >>

New York [USA], Apr. 26 (ANI): A California judge has blocked US President Donald Trump's executive order that sought to withhold federal funds to "sanctuary cities", the communities that have refused to work with Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials after detaining illegal immigrants.

Full Story >>

Kabul [Afghanistan], Apr 26 (ANI): Former Afghan president Hamid Karzai met with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in Moscow on Tuesday and discussed Afghanistan and regional security.

Full Story >>

China launches first indigenously built aircraft carrier

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 12:36 IST     

Dalian [China], Apr 26 (ANI): China on Wednesday launched its second aircraft carrier, the first to be developed and built indigenously, in a Dalian shipyard in Liaoning Province.

Full Story >>

Peshawar [Pakistan], Apr 26 (ANI): Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) chief Imran Khan has accused the Nawaz Sharif-led Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) regime of offering him Rs10 billion to back down from the Panamagate case.

Full Story >>

Karachi [Pakistan], Apr 26 (ANI): Three militants believed to be associated with the Tehreek-e-Taliban Swat (TTS) and Jundullah, a female facilitator and her five-year-old daughter were killed in a paramilitary force operation in Karachi's Urdu Bazaar area.

Full Story >>

Dhaka [Bangladesh], Apr 26 (ANI): Security forces cordoned off a one-storied house at Chapainawabganj's Shibganj upazila in Bangladesh this morning after suspecting the presence of a militant hideout.

Full Story >>

Dawn leaks report to be submitted to PM Sharif today

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 11:12 IST     

Islamabad [Pakistan], Apr 26 (ANI): Pakistan's Ministry of Interior said has received the Dawn leaks report which will be submitted to Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif today.

Full Story >>

US' THAAD equipment installation underway in South Korea

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 10:20 IST     

Seoul/Seongju [South Korea], April 26 (ANI): The U.S. troops in South Korea began installing the equipment for the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD), an advanced missile defense system.

Full Story >>

Moscow [Russia], Apr 26 (ANI): Representatives of the Russian airline Aeroflot have said that it is reasonable for the female flight attendants to face financial penalties if they are deemed overweight.

Full Story >>

Pakistan: 14 killed as landmine blast hits van in Kurram

Updated: Apr 26, 2017 08:34 IST     

Peshawar [Pakistan], Apr 26 (ANI): At least 14 people were killed when a passenger vehicle hit an anti-tank mine in Gudar area of Central Kurram Agency early Tuesday.

Full Story >>

Washington D.C. [USA], Apr 26 (ANI): Law enforcement officials across six cities in Washington, DC, metropolitan area on Wednesday will conduct a full scale drill to prepare for terror attacks.

Full Story >>