Mon, May 29, 2017 | updated 05:49 AM IST

India cannot revoke Indus Waters Treaty unilaterally: Pak lawyer

Updated: Sep 27, 2016 16:38 IST      
India cannot revoke Indus Waters Treaty unilaterally: Pak lawyer

Islamabad [Pakistan], Sept. 27 (ANI): Ahmer Bilal Soofi, Pakistan's former law minister, president Research Society of International Law and an advocate in the Supreme Court on the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), has said that India has no legal competence under the treaty to revoke it per se on its own, adding the treaty has no provision for unilateral "suspension".

In an interview to Dawn, Soofi gave his opinions on the Indus Waters Treaty after Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met with officials to review provisions with Pakistan.

In the meeting, New Delhi ruled out cancelling the Indus Waters Treaty (1960) but said that it is looking for ways of increasing its use of waters that flow from India but are controlled by Pakistan.

Soofi maintained that if the treaty is to end, a termination treaty has to be drafted by both India and Pakistan and then ratified by both.

"India has no legal competence under the treaty to revoke it per se on its own. Article 12(4) of the treaty entitles the termination of the treaty only if both India and Pakistan agree in writing. In other words, a termination treaty has to be drafted by both states and then ratified by both, to bring the IWT to an end. The treaty has no provision for unilateral "suspension"," he said.

Insisting that IWT is not regime-specific but rather state-specific, he said the treaty would not expire with regime change and it is binding on both the states equally and offers no exit provision.

He said that walking away from a treaty is in effect will be a breach.

"If India unilaterally stops following the treaty by giving any justification such as "revocation", "suspension", "withdrawal" or "annulment" etc. then it really means that it has decided to interrupt the water flow into Pakistan. In other words what India will call "revocation or withdrawal", Pakistan will refer to as a "breach"," he added.

Soofi said that in case India "revokes" the treaty, it literally means it has shunned it and there is no provision in the IWT about its duration or suspension, adding there is no avenue that Pakistan can approach for "revival" of the treaty.

"Since there is no provision in the IWT about its duration or suspension, there is no avenue that Pakistan can approach for "revival" of the treaty. Nor can Pakistan approach the International Court of Justice seeking specific performance to implement the treaty because of the Indian reservation given under ICJ statute that bars filing of case by Pakistan against India, " he added.

On being asked if India stops Pakistani waters downstream, could this set a precedent for China upstream on Brahmaputra river, Soofi said, "In case India tries to interrupt water flow into Pakistan as an upper riparian, it is setting up a regional state practice which under international law can serve as a precedence and equip China with an argument to consider suspension of the waters of Brahmaputra river."

He pointed out that India may have already damaged itself by even considering the suspension of water flow as an upper riparian and the Chinese Government must be watching New Delhi's moves with interest.

The treaty was inked in 1960 by the India's first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru and then Pakistan President Ayub Khan, which allocates 80 percent of water to Pakistan from the six-river Indus Water System, including Beas, Ravi, Sutlej, Indus, Chenab and Jhelum that flows from India to Pakistan.

The treaty, brokered by the World Bank, is often considered to be one-sided and there has been growing clamour to relook at it. The pact has survived wars and phases of frosty ties between India and Pakistan. (ANI)

Washington D. C. [USA], May 29 (ANI): U.S. Defense Secretary James Mattis on Sunday said that civilian casualties in the fight against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) are inevitable even as the U.S. forces "do everything humanly possible" to prevent them.

Full Story >>

Somalia: Jihadist group stones man to death for adultery

Updated: May 29, 2017 05:11 IST     

Moscow [Russia], May 29 (ANI): Jihadist group al-Shabaab reportedly stoned to death a 44-year-old man in Somalia for alleged adultery.

Full Story >>

Moscow [Russia], May 29 (ANI): The missile launched by North Korea on Monday reached Japan's exclusive economic zone in the Sea of Japan, said Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga.

Full Story >>

N. Korea launches 'what appears to be' ballistic missile

Updated: May 29, 2017 03:45 IST     

Seoul [South Korea], May 29 (ANI): North Korea on Monday fired what appears to be a ballistic missile from its eastern coast, according to the South Korean military.

Full Story >>

Europe can no longer rely on U.S., Britain: Merkel

Updated: May 29, 2017 03:23 IST     

Berlin [Germany], May 29 (ANI): German Chancellor Angela Merkel said Europe has to forge its own path forward, as the United States and Britain are no longer reliable partners.

Full Story >>

US-led airstrike kills 20 civilians in Syria

Updated: May 29, 2017 03:19 IST     

Raqqa [Syria], May 29 (ANI): At least 20 civilians were killed in a U.S. led airstrike against the Islamic State terrorists in the southern countryside of Raqqa province in Syria.

Full Story >>

U.S. considering laptop ban on all international flights

Updated: May 29, 2017 01:12 IST     

Washington D.C. [USA], May 29 (ANI): The U.S. administration is considering a blanket ban on laptops in passenger cabins of all international flights to and from the United States.

Full Story >>

Suicide bomb attack kills four in eastern Iraq

Updated: May 28, 2017 23:15 IST     

Diyala [Iraq], May 28 (ANI): At least four persons were killed and 18 others injured after a suicide bomber blew himself near a security checkpoint in Iraq's central Baquba city on Sunday.

Full Story >>

New Delhi [India], May 28 (ANI): United States President Donald Trump has said that British Prime Minister Theresa May was very angry over the leaks of sensitive information about the Manchester Arena bombing to the U.S. media.

Full Story >>

Eight killed in Mississippi shooting, one arrested

Updated: May 28, 2017 20:27 IST     

Mississippi [USA], May 28 (ANI): At least eight people including a deputy sheriff were killed in shoot out in Mississippi's Lincoln County.

Full Story >>

Kathmandu sees Tagore's childhood

Updated: May 28, 2017 18:14 IST      By: Binod Prasad Adhikari

Kathmandu [Nepal], May 28 (ANI): Indian theater group, Ruchika, on Sunday staged a drama based on famous literary figure Rabindranath Tagore's childhood in Kathmandu.

Full Story >>

China criticises G7 interference in its sea disputes

Updated: May 28, 2017 17:30 IST     

Beijing [China], May 28 (ANI): China's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lu Kang on Sunday said that Beijing strongly denounces a joint communique released after the 2017 G7 summit as it interfered in East China Sea and South China Sea issues on the pretext of international law.

Full Story >>

Nawaz Sharif's son appears before JIT in Panamagate probe

Updated: May 28, 2017 15:59 IST     

Islamabad [Pakistan], May 28 (ANI): Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif's son Hussain Nawaz on Sunday appeared before the Supreme Court-appointed Joint Investigation Team (JIT) probing the Sharif family's offshore properties to record his statement in the ongoing Panamagate probe at the Federal Judicial Academy.

Full Story >>

INS Shardul reaches Colombo with relief materials

Updated: May 28, 2017 15:29 IST     

Colombo [Sri Lanka], May 28 (ANI): In the aftermath of devastating floods and landslides in Sri Lanka, the Indian Navy's INS Shardul on Sunday reached here with relief materials and stores.

Full Story >>

Saudi rulers will perish: Khamenei

Updated: May 28, 2017 15:11 IST     

Tehran [Iran], May 28 (ANI): On the occasion of the beginning of the holy fasting month of Ramadan, Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei said that "Saudi rulers are going to perish".

Full Story >>

Trump returns to White House, faces slew of challenges

Updated: May 28, 2017 15:11 IST     

New York [U.S.], May 28 (ANI) : U.S. President Donald Trump is facing a barrage of challenges including Jared Kushner's role in the ongoing Russian probe, after coming back to the White House after his first international trip, during which he visited Saudi Arabia, Israel, Italy, the Vatican and Belgium over a period of nine days.

Full Story >>

Massive power outages across Karachi on first day of Ramazan

Updated: May 28, 2017 14:43 IST     

Karachi [Pakistan], May 28 (ANI): Pakistan's largest and most populous city, Karachi suffered massive power outages on Sunday, the first day of Ramazan.

Full Story >>

Kim Jong Un inspects test-fire of new anti-aircraft weapon

Updated: May 28, 2017 13:28 IST     

Moscow [Russia], May 28 (ANI): Supreme leader of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) Kim Jong-un has ordered the mass-production and deployment of a 'next-gen air defense system' to bolster its air supremacy as he personally inspected the test-fire of a new-type anti-aircraft guided weapon system.

Full Story >>

Lahore [Pakistan], May 28 (ANI): A petition has been filed in Pakistan's Supreme Court seeking 'immediate execution' of alleged Indian spy Kulbhushan Jadhav if he failed to get his capital punishment overturned.

Full Story >>

UK: 23,000 jihadists identified amid terror fears

Updated: May 28, 2017 12:03 IST     

London [U.K.], May 28 (ANI): As many as 23,000 jihadist extremists currently living in the U.K. have been identified by intelligence agencies as potential terrorists.

Full Story >>