Thu, Jul 27, 2017 | updated 10:36 AM IST

India can approach UNSC if Pak rejects ICJ's order on Jadhav

Updated: May 18, 2017 18:47 IST      
India can approach UNSC if Pak rejects ICJ's order on Jadhav

New Delhi [India], May 18 (ANI): India can and may approach United Nations Security Council should Pakistan refuse to abide by the stay order of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on the execution of Kulbhushan Jadhav.

The UN charter entails that 'each member of the United Nations undertakes to comply with the decision of the International Court of Justice' and 'if any party to a case fails to perform the obligations, the other party may have recourse to the Security Council.

Here is the text of the ICJ's order:

In a major win for India, the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the primary judicial organ of the United Nations, has ordered Pakistan to take "all measures at its disposal" to prevent the execution of an Indian national Kulbhushan Jadhav, until its final order.

In its order indicating provisional measures, which was adopted unanimously, the Court also stated that the Pakistan Government shall inform it of all measures taken in implementation of that order.

It further decided to remain seised of the matters which form the subject of the order until it has rendered its final judgment.

The Court began by considering whether it has jurisdiction prima facie to hear the case.

It recalled that India seeks to ground its jurisdiction in Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention, which provides that the Court has jurisdiction over "disputes arising out of theinterpretation or application of the Vienna Convention".

In this regard, the Court noted that the both sides do indeed appear to have differed and still differ today on the question of India's consular assistance to Jadhav under the Vienna Convention.

It further noted that the acts alleged by India that is the alleged failure by Pakistan to provide the requisite consular notifications with regard to the arrest and detention of Mr. Jadhav, as well as the alleged failure to allow communication and provide access to him, appeared to be capable of falling within the scope of the Convention.

In the view of the Court, this is sufficient to establish that it has prima facie jurisdiction under Article I of the optional protocol.

The Court further observed that the existence of a 2008 bilateral agreement between the two countries on consular relations does not change its conclusion on jurisdiction.

The court then turned to the question whether the rights alleged by India are at least plausible.

It observed that the rights to consular notification and access between a State and its nationals, as well as the obligations of the detaining state to inform the person concerned without delay of hisrights with regard to consular assistance and to allow their exercise, are recognized in Article 36, paragraph 1, of the Vienna Convention, and that India has alleged violations of this provision.

In the view of the Court, therefore, it appears that the rights alleged by India are plausible.

The Court then focused on the issue of the link between the rights claimed and the provisional measures requested.

It considered that the measures requested are aimed at ensuring that the rights contained in Article 36, paragraph 1, of the Vienna Convention and are preserved. Therefore, a link exists between the rights claimed by India and the provisional measures being sought.

The Court then examined whether there is a risk of irreparable prejudice and urgency.

It considered that the mere fact that Jadhav is under a death sentence and might therefore be executed is sufficient to demonstrate the existence of a risk of irreparable prejudice to the rights claimed by India.

The Court further observes that Pakistan has indicated that any execution of Jadhav would probably not take place before the month of August 2017.

This means that there is a risk that an execution could take place at any moment thereafter, before the Court has given its final decision in the case.

The Court also noted that Pakistan has given no assurance that Jadhav will not be executed before the Court has rendered its final decision.

In those circumstances, the Court said that there is urgency in the present case.

The Court concluded by indicating the following measures:

1.) Pakistan shall take all measures at its disposal to ensure that Mr. Jadhav is not executed pending the final decision in these proceedings and shall inform the Court of all the measures takenin implementation of the present Order.

2.) The Court also decides that, until it has given its final decision, it shall remain seised of the matters which form the subject-matter of this Order.

Justice Ronny Abraham of the ICJ read out the much-awaited verdict and asserted that the case was indeed debatable, while also adding that the ICJ had prime facie jurisdiction in the case.

Abraham added that under the Vienna Convention, India should have received consular access to seek justice for the former Indian Naval officer.

A Pakistan military court had awarded the death sentence to former Indian naval officer Jadhav on April 10 for alleged "espionage and subversive activities."

However, India, after being denied consular access for 16th time, dragged Pakistan to the ICJ on May 8 for violating the Vienna Convention.

India told the ICJ that immediate steps must be taken to stop Pakistan from carrying out the death sentence of Jadhav. Demanding the immediate suspension of the death sentence, New Delhi expressed fear that Islamabad might execute the formal naval officer even before the hearing of the ICJ was over.

Pakistan, on its part, told the ICJ that the provisions of Vienna Convention on consular access were not applicable for a 'spy'. It also accused India of using the international body for political theatrics.

Arguing before the 11-judge bench at the ICJ, which included former Supreme Court Judge Dalveer Bhandari, India's counsel Harish Salve stressed that not granting consular access and not giving legal representation of Jadhav's choosing amounted to a "miscarriage of justice" and a "violation of his right" to defend himself from concocted charges in a "farcical trial".

India told the ICJ that immediate steps must be taken to stop Pakistan's from carrying out the death sentence of Jadhav.

Salve had told the court that India couldn't arrange for Jadhav's defence due to denial of consular access by Pakistan. He said India made innumerable requests for consular access, but Pakistan refused to provide documents relating to the case and consular access to him.

Pakistan raised the confession statement of Jadhav as a base of its argument and accused India of using the ICJ for its "political theatrics." India termed that the confession of Jadhav was forcibly taken by the military while in captivity and he was tried by a military court in Pakistan.

Pakistan's counsel Khawar Qureshi, while presenting Islamabad's stance in the ICJ on death sentence handed to Jadhav, said that the former naval officer entered Islamabad through Iran using a fake passport.

He told the court that Pakistan had given India all information regarding Jadhav's investigation, but didn't receive any response from New Delhi.

India demanded the immediate suspension of Jadhav's death sentence but Pakistan presented the Kulbhushan Jadhav case as a matter of national security and the ICJ's decision would not apply to "matters related to the national security of Pakistan." (ANI)

Islamabad [Pakistan], July 27 (ANI): Pakistan's Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan has sought an explanation for being not called in consultative meetings of ruling Pakistan Muslim League's (PML-N) and wanted to know if the decision was made due to his opposing stance, or due to some other reason.

Full Story >>

Imran for early SC judgement in Panamagate

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 09:27 IST     

Islamabad [Pakistan], July 27 (ANI): Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf Chairman Imran Khan has said that the Supreme Court should give the verdict regarding the Panama Leaks case soon as the country is in a sense of stalemate.

Full Story >>

Ajit Doval arrives in Beijing to attend BRICS NSA's meet

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 08:32 IST     

Beijing [China], July 27 (ANI): Amid Doklam standoff between India and China, Indian National Security Adviser Ajit Doval arrived in Beijing on Thursday to attend the BRICS NSA's meeting on July 27-28.

Full Story >>

CIA brands China as long-term security challenge to U.S.

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 07:12 IST     

New York [U.S.A], July 27 (ANI): CIA Director Mike Pompeo has branded China as one of the biggest threat to America's super power status in the world, than Russia or Iran.

Full Story >>

Houthi rebels target Saudi oil facility with Scud missile

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 06:29 IST     

New York [U.S.A], July 27 (ANI): Yemen's Houthi rebels fired a Scud missile to target a oil facility near the port city of Yanbu in Saudi Arabia.

Full Story >>

North Korea to launch missile on Victory Day

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 05:31 IST     

Washington [U.S.A.] , July 27 (ANI): North Korea is likely to test fire another intercontinental ballistic missile on Thursday as July 27 marks the 64th anniversary of the signing of armistice that ended the Korean War.

Full Story >>

New York [U.S.A.], July 27 (ANI):U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday called a reporter "very rude" for posing him a question on his newly announced ban on transgenders in the military, during his address to the American Legion youth at the White House lawn.

Full Story >>

Trump describes American Legion youth as 'next gen leaders'

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 04:12 IST     

New York [U.S.A.], July 27 (ANI): While addressing the American Legion youth at the White House, U.S. President Donald Trump described them as the "the next generation of American leaders" and praised his administration's "job numbers" for being the best "in 17 years."

Full Story >>

Senate vote fails to repeal, replace Obamacare

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 03:08 IST     

New York [U.S.A.], July 27 (ANI): The Senate has defeated the proposal by Republicans to repeal much of former President Barack Obama's health care law 'Obamacare' and replace it with a more restrictive plan.

Full Story >>

Beijing [China], July 27 (ANI): The Chinese veterans, who fought the war on the Sino-Indian border 55 years ago, have vowed to send their children to the battle field if another war breaks out.

Full Story >>

U.S. coalition continue strikes against ISIS in Syria, Iraq

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 02:20 IST     

New York [U.S.], July 27 (ANI) :U.S. and coalition military forces continued to attack the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria conducting 27 strikes, consisting of 32 engagements, inflicting major damage to radical Islamic forces and tactical units.

Full Story >>

New York [U.S.A], July 27 (ANI): U.S. President Donald Trump's move of reversing former President Barack Obama's policy of allowing transgenders to serve in the US armed forces drew swift condemnation from Senator John McCain and rights groups.

Full Story >>

Trump continues attacks on Sessions

Updated: Jul 27, 2017 01:04 IST     

New York [U.S.], July 27 (ANI) :U.S. President Donald Trump continued his attacks on the Attorney General Jeff Sessions, over Twitter, for not replacing the acting FBI Director McCabe and also renewed accusations about investigations against Hillary Clinton.

Full Story >>

EU warns Poland over controversial judicial reform bills

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 23:37 IST     

Istanbul [Turkey], July 26 (ANI): The European Union (EU) has warned Poland of suspending its voting rights after the country recently approved two controversial judicial reforms that would give the government broad powers in the nomination of judges.

Full Story >>

40 Afghan soldiers killed in Taliban attack at military base

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 20:28 IST     

Kabul [Afghanistan], July 26 (ANI): At least 40 Afghan soldiers were killed and 40 injured after the Taliban attacked the Afghan Army base in the southern Kandahar province of Afghanistan.

Full Story >>

President Trump bars transgenders from serving U.S. military

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 20:17 IST     

New Delhi [India], Jul 26 (ANI): United States President Donald Trump on Wednesday announced that transgenders, in any capacity, won't be allowed to serve the military saying that their inclusion would entail "disruption" in the military affairs.

Full Story >>

New York [U.S.A], July 26 (ANI): American federal agencies arrested Florida Democratic representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz's top information technology (IT) aide for trying to board a Pakistan bound flight after he transferred USD 283,000 to Islamabad.

Full Story >>

Nepal PM expands cabinet, inducts 19 new Ministers

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 17:53 IST     

Kathmandu [Nepal], July 26 (ANI): Nepal Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba on Wednesday expanded his cabinet by inducting 19 new ministers.

Full Story >>

China hails PM Modi's active foreign policy amid Doklam row

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 17:53 IST     

Beijing [China], July 26 (ANI): China has lauded Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's active foreign policy, saying that he has reformed the country's foreign investment policy and encouraged domestic enterprises to go into the international market.

Full Story >>

China warns Botswana over Dalai Lama's visit

Updated: Jul 26, 2017 17:53 IST     

Beijing [China], Jul 26 (ANI): China on Wednesday warned Botswana over Tibetan spiritual leader Dalai Lama's visit next month, asking the African nation to respect Beijing's 'core interests' and make a wise decision.

Full Story >>